Comparison
Premium Impact Screen vs simDIY Premium Impact Screen
When you buy through links on Northcourse, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Read the full affiliate disclosure
A side-by-side look at how the Carl's Place Premium Impact Screen and Rain or Shine Golf simDIY Premium Impact Screen compare on specs, accuracy, room requirements, and price. No hype — just the parts of the decision a buyer actually weighs.
Also worth a look
More comparisons with the Premium Impact Screen and simDIY Premium Impact Screen
High-Contrast Gray Impact Screen vs simDIY Premium Impact Screen$450 · $449
simDIY Premium Impact Screen vs Deluxe Practice Net$449 · $450
High-Contrast Gray Impact Screen vs Premium Impact Screen$450 · $440- Premium Impact Screen vs Deluxe Practice Net$440 · $450
Premium Impact Screen vs Double Sided Impact Screen$440 · $400- simDIY Premium Impact Screen vs Double Sided Impact Screen$449 · $400
Buy Premium Impact Screen
- Buy at PlayBetter $440Free ship, Premium Impact Screen
- Buy at Indoor Golf Outlet $440Free ship, Premium Impact Screen
Prices confirmed Nov 10, 2026 · we check every retailer daily
Buy simDIY Premium Impact Screen
Prices confirmed Nov 10, 2026 · we check every retailer daily
When you buy through links on Northcourse, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Read the full affiliate disclosure
Full specificationsEvery spec for both, line by line
Specifications
The numbers, lined up.
Hardware
| Spec | Premium Impact Screen | simDIY Premium Impact Screen |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Impact screen only (no frame) | Impact screen only (no frame) |
| Construction | Dense multilayer fabric; rated to 250 mph | — |
| Finish | Classic: 2.5" black vinyl edges with grommets; flaps or loop fastener optional | — |
| Material | — | Ballistic-grade woven polyester; vinyl-coated border, 3/8" grommets |
- TypePremium Impact ScreenImpact screen only (no frame)simDIY Premium Impact ScreenImpact screen only (no frame)
- ConstructionPremium Impact ScreenDense multilayer fabric; rated to 250 mphsimDIY Premium Impact Screen—
- FinishPremium Impact ScreenClassic: 2.5" black vinyl edges with grommets; flaps or loop fastener optionalsimDIY Premium Impact Screen—
- MaterialPremium Impact Screen—simDIY Premium Impact ScreenBallistic-grade woven polyester; vinyl-coated border, 3/8" grommets
Dimensions
| Spec | Premium Impact Screen | simDIY Premium Impact Screen |
|---|---|---|
| Size We Link | 7.7' × 7.7' (1:1), Classic finish ($439.95) | 7.7' H × 10' W, 4:3 ($449) |
| Other Sizes | 29 sizes, 1:1 to 16:9, up to 10' × 18' | 8 × 10.5 and 9 × 12 (4:3); 8 × 14 and 9 × 16 (16:9), up to $699 |
- Size We LinkPremium Impact Screen7.7' × 7.7' (1:1), Classic finish ($439.95)simDIY Premium Impact Screen7.7' H × 10' W, 4:3 ($449)
- Other SizesPremium Impact Screen29 sizes, 1:1 to 16:9, up to 10' × 18'simDIY Premium Impact Screen8 × 10.5 and 9 × 12 (4:3); 8 × 14 and 9 × 16 (16:9), up to $699
Requirements
| Spec | Premium Impact Screen | simDIY Premium Impact Screen |
|---|---|---|
| Frame Gap | — | At least 2" each side between screen and frame (Indoor Golf Outlet) |
- Frame GapPremium Impact Screen—simDIY Premium Impact ScreenAt least 2" each side between screen and frame (Indoor Golf Outlet)
Persona fitWho each one is better for
Who each one is better for
Both fit the same buyers.
Neither one wins a persona the other doesn’t. The choice comes down to specs, price, and room fit rather than buyer profile.
Both fit
- Cost-Effective Buyer
Build your simulator in two minutes
Five questions. One tailored build with retailer links.
We ask about your budget, your room, and how you’ll use it. We return a complete build — launch monitor, mat, enclosure, projector, software, PC — with the reasoning behind every pick and the alternatives we considered.