Comparison
C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) vs Simulator Bay (Sim 8)
When you buy through links on Northcourse, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Read the full affiliate disclosure
A side-by-side look at how the Carl's Place C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) and Net Return Simulator Bay (Sim 8) compare on specs, accuracy, room requirements, and price. No hype — just the parts of the decision a buyer actually weighs.
Also worth a look
More comparisons with the C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) and Simulator Bay (Sim 8)
C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) vs Motorized Drop-Down Golf Simulator Enclosure$1,750 · $1,963
C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) vs ProScreen 180 Retractable$1,750 · $1,999
C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) vs SIG10 Enclosure$1,750 · $2,000
C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) vs Motorized Retractable Impact Screen$1,750 · $1,257
C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) vs Foldable Golf Simulator Enclosure$1,750 · $2,338
C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) vs SIG12 Enclosure$1,750 · $2,500
Buy C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)
Show all 2 retailersShow fewer retailers
Prices confirmed Nov 10, 2026 · we check every retailer daily
Buy Simulator Bay (Sim 8)
Show all 2 retailersShow fewer retailers
Prices confirmed Nov 10, 2026 · we check every retailer daily
When you buy through links on Northcourse, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Read the full affiliate disclosure
Full specificationsEvery spec for both, line by line
Specifications
The numbers, lined up.
Hardware
| Spec | C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) | Simulator Bay (Sim 8) |
|---|---|---|
| Screen Material | Premium 3-layer spacer mesh | — |
| Screen Tiers Available | Standard / Preferred / Premium / High-Contrast Gray (price varies) | — |
| Both-Handed Friendly | Yes — 12 ft wide | — |
| Type | — | Freestanding aluminum-frame bay with netting, side barriers and floating screen |
| Screen | — | Floating HD screen with valance; size not published |
- Screen MaterialC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)Premium 3-layer spacer meshSimulator Bay (Sim 8)—
- Screen Tiers AvailableC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)Standard / Preferred / Premium / High-Contrast Gray (price varies)Simulator Bay (Sim 8)—
- Both-Handed FriendlyC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)Yes — 12 ft wideSimulator Bay (Sim 8)—
- TypeC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)—Simulator Bay (Sim 8)Freestanding aluminum-frame bay with netting, side barriers and floating screen
- ScreenC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)—Simulator Bay (Sim 8)Floating HD screen with valance; size not published
Dimensions
| Spec | C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) | Simulator Bay (Sim 8) |
|---|---|---|
| Frame (outer) | 112" H × 146.3" W × 59.125" D; the rear fitting adds 8.25" (67.375" of floor depth) | — |
| Viewable Screen | 132.3" × 99.2" (4:3, 165.4" diagonal) | — |
| Size We Link | — | Sim 8: 8' W × 8'6" H × 3'6" D (Net Return); Indoor Golf Outlet lists 8'10" H ($1,995) |
| Other Sizes | — | Sim 10 (10' wide, $2,495); Sim 12 (12' wide, $2,995) |
- Frame (outer)C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)112" H × 146.3" W × 59.125" D; the rear fitting adds 8.25" (67.375" of floor depth)Simulator Bay (Sim 8)—
- Viewable ScreenC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)132.3" × 99.2" (4:3, 165.4" diagonal)Simulator Bay (Sim 8)—
- Size We LinkC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)—Simulator Bay (Sim 8)Sim 8: 8' W × 8'6" H × 3'6" D (Net Return); Indoor Golf Outlet lists 8'10" H ($1,995)
- Other SizesC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)—Simulator Bay (Sim 8)Sim 10 (10' wide, $2,495); Sim 12 (12' wide, $2,995)
Requirements
| Spec | C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) | Simulator Bay (Sim 8) |
|---|---|---|
| Clearance | At least 2–3" above and 2–3" each side; 8.25" minimum behind, 12" recommended (Carl's) | — |
| Room Minimum | — | 10' W × 9' H × 14' L for the Sim 8 (Net Return); 6" behind the bay |
- ClearanceC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)At least 2–3" above and 2–3" each side; 8.25" minimum behind, 12" recommended (Carl's)Simulator Bay (Sim 8)—
- Room MinimumC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)—Simulator Bay (Sim 8)10' W × 9' H × 14' L for the Sim 8 (Net Return); 6" behind the bay
Practical
| Spec | C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) | Simulator Bay (Sim 8) |
|---|---|---|
| Setup Time | About 1 hour of assembly (Carl's figure), plus buying and cutting the EMT | — |
| Warranty | — | Net 3 years / 250,000 shots; screen 1 year (Net Return) |
- Setup TimeC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)About 1 hour of assembly (Carl's figure), plus buying and cutting the EMTSimulator Bay (Sim 8)—
- WarrantyC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)—Simulator Bay (Sim 8)Net 3 years / 250,000 shots; screen 1 year (Net Return)
Performance
| Spec | C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen) | Simulator Bay (Sim 8) |
|---|---|---|
| Ball Speed Rating | — | 225 mph (Net Return; Indoor Golf Outlet says 250) |
- Ball Speed RatingC-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)—Simulator Bay (Sim 8)225 mph (Net Return; Indoor Golf Outlet says 250)
Persona fitWho each one is better for
Who each one is better for
Honest persona fit, side by side.
Better for C-Series DIY Enclosure (9x12, Premium screen)
- Performance Seeker
Premium 3-layer spacer mesh screen reduces bounce-back that affects launch-monitor accuracy. 9×12 size accommodates full driver swing arc with comfortable bounce-back room.
Better for Simulator Bay (Sim 8)
- Recreational Player
Tool-free color-coded connectors and a 3'6" deep frame, from the brand most people already know for practice nets.
Both fit
- Family Setup
Build your simulator in two minutes
Five questions. One tailored build with retailer links.
We ask about your budget, your room, and how you’ll use it. We return a complete build — launch monitor, mat, enclosure, projector, software, PC — with the reasoning behind every pick and the alternatives we considered.